Skip to Main Content

That Nagging Ankle: When to Worry (and When Not To)

By John Galligan, MD January 21, 2025 Posted in: Orthopedics

Understanding Common Ankle Injuries

As an orthopedic foot and ankle specialist, I see a lot of ankle injuries. From the weekend warrior's sprain to the unfortunate fall on the ice, the ankle is a surprisingly vulnerable joint. And while many ankle issues resolve themselves with a little RICE (Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation), knowing when to seek professional help is crucial. I’ll shed some light on common ankle problems and when you should schedule an appointment to see an orthopedic surgeon.

Mild vs. Severe Ankle Sprains

The most common culprit is the ankle sprain. This occurs when the ligaments supporting the ankle joint are stretched or torn. Mild sprains often present with mild swelling, pain, and some difficulty walking. You might be able to bear weight, albeit with discomfort. These usually heal within a few weeks with conservative management – that RICE protocol I mentioned earlier, along with over-the-counter pain relievers. However, moderate to severe sprains, characterized by significant swelling, intense pain, inability to bear weight, and instability, require immediate medical attention. These can involve significant ligament damage and may necessitate immobilization, physical therapy, or even surgery.

Recognizing the Signs of Ankle Fractures

Beyond sprains, fractures are another serious concern. A fall, a direct blow, or a twisting injury can all result in a fracture. The telltale signs are often intense pain, significant swelling, deformity of the ankle, and an inability to bear weight. If you suspect a fracture, get to the emergency room immediately. X-rays are essential for diagnosis, and prompt treatment is crucial for proper healing and preventing long-term complications.

Underlying Causes of Chronic Ankle Pain

Then there are the less obvious issues. Chronic ankle pain, even without a specific injury, can be a sign of underlying problems like arthritis, tendonitis, or impingement. Arthritis can cause persistent stiffness and pain, particularly in older individuals. Tendonitis, inflammation of the tendons around the ankle, often presents with localized pain and tenderness. Impingement, where bones or tissues rub against each other, can cause pain with certain movements. These conditions often require a more comprehensive evaluation, potentially including imaging studies like MRI scans, to determine the best course of treatment.

Ankle Pain and Cold Weather

Many patients report increased ankle pain during colder months. This can be due to several factors. Reduced blood flow to the extremities in cold weather can lead to stiffness and increased pain in already injured or arthritic ankles. Additionally, the increased risk of falls on icy surfaces contributes to a higher incidence of ankle injuries during winter. Proper footwear with good traction is crucial during cold and icy conditions.

Tips for Preventing Ankle Injuries

Finally, don't underestimate the power of proper footwear and preventative measures. Supportive shoes, appropriate athletic gear, and regular stretching can significantly reduce your risk of ankle injuries. Listen to your body. If the pain persists beyond a few days, or if you experience any of the warning signs mentioned above, don't hesitate to seek professional medical advice. Early intervention can often prevent long-term problems and ensure a faster, more complete recovery. Your ankles are essential for mobility – let's keep them healthy!

John Galligan, MD
John Galligan, MD

John D. Galligan, MD, is an orthopedic foot and ankle surgeon with CHI Health.

Related Articles

Understanding ACL Tears and ACL Reconstruction

FEB 17, 2025

Recover faster from an ACL tear with minimally invasive all-inside reconstruction. This advanced technique and can get you back to your active life sooner.

Read More

Is Total Knee Replacement Your Only Option for Osteoarthritis?

FEB 17, 2025

Discover if a minimally invasive partial knee replacement is a better alternative to total knee replacement for your osteoarthritis.

Read More

Hip Pain in the Groin? Understanding and Treating Hip Arthritis

FEB 17, 2025

Experience less pain and faster recovery with anterior hip replacement surgery, a minimally invasive approach to treating hip arthritis.

Read More