Skip to Main Content

Oh, the Weather Outside is Frightful

By Eric Van De Graaff, MD January 18, 2010 Posted in: Heart Health

There’s an iconic image from legendary medical illustrator Frank Netter, MD that I will never forget from my medical school days. It’s a picture of a man clutching his chest as he exits a restaurant to trudge into the snowy night. The artwork was originally published in 1969 as part of the CIBA Collection of Medical Illustrations that serves as the benchmark for anatomic art in the last half century. I’d venture that there is not a doctor on the planet who is not familiar with the artistic footprint of Dr. Netter.

This particular picture accompanies the section of the atlas pertaining to “angina pectoris,” the chest pain that arises when the heart muscle is not getting an adequate supply of blood and oxygen. While the symptoms can be variable, angina is most often described as a squeezing pressure in the chest. As is typical of Dr. Netter’s style, his illustration captures many of the subtleties of the subject described. The man is middle-aged and mildly overweight and one can clearly see the burning ember of a cigarette butt he’s dropped into the snow. He is coming out of a restaurant and lumbering up a couple of steps into the driving winter wind. His right hand claws at his chest (see Levine sign) as his left hand loses its grip on his brief case.

In this illustration, Dr. Netter has made sure all the elements are there for a classic case of angina.

Risk factors? Check.

Exertion? Check.

Recent culinary indiscretion at a local pub? Check.

Driving snow and winter wind? Now it’s getting personal.

Those of us in the Midwest have had our share of arctic conditions over the last month as our temperatures hover well below freezing for what seems like an eternity and snow blankets our region to a degree that’s not been seen in years. The deep drifts have brought with them the familiar early morning buzz of snow blowers being reluctantly fired up for action, and, with that, come the admissions to the hospital of patients with heart attacks and chest pain.

While this is something I can’t quantify with any reliable objective data, my feeling is that I have seen more patients this year with heart conditions exacerbated by the elements than I’ve seen in years past. Is this just my imagination—my mind, being driven mad by the numbness of the arctic chill—or is there evidence linking a miserable winter to a rise in heart disease?

Indeed, solid research confirms the link between a bad winter and a rise in the rate of cardiac events. In one study, published in the British Journal of Medicine in 2004, researchers tracked temperature and climate data from 24 different countries in an attempt to establish a link between lousy weather and heart attacks. They discovered that a strong relationship exists between low temperature and the population’s rate of heart attacks and stroke. Their conclusions were so robust that they were able to provide an algorithm for determining what sort of rise in problems we can expect with cold air: “On average, a 5°C reduction in mean air temperature was associated with a 7% and 12% increase in the expected hospitalization rates of stroke and AMI (heart attack), respectively.” (How would it be if we added that to our evening weather broadcast? “And for tomorrow we can expect a high of 5 degrees, winds out of the north at 15 mph, and scattered heart attacks throughout the metro area.”)

Another study, published in the journal Circulation the same year, showed that the risk of cardiac-related death is at its absolute highest in the period between Christmas and New Years Day. The authors are careful to point out that it’s not clear whether the increased prevalence of heart attacks is due to the cold weather or the abundance of stale fruitcakes and spiked eggnog.

What, exactly, are the possible factors that lead to winter heart attacks in susceptible individuals? Here are some possibilities:

  1. The body shunts more blood to the skin when the air is cold to maintain body temperature. To do this the heart needs to work harder to cycle the blood volume more quickly.
  2. Depression, long linked to the cold darkness of winter, is known to be a risk factor for cardiovascular disease.
  3. Flu and cold viruses can trigger inflammatory responses in the coronary arteries that can disrupt the delicate balance of coronary cholesterol plaques.
  4. People generally exercise less when the weather is bad and slip into worse physical condition. Just this week Circulation published a study linking risk of cardiac death to the number of hours a person sits glued to American Idol.
  5. People tend to eat more, smoke more, and gain more weight during the holiday season.

At the precise moment a person with occult coronary disease is at his deconditioned, flabbiest worst, he decides it’s time to man up and get out in the subzero temperature to perform his own stress test behind a 75-lb snow blower. It’s no surprise the night ends up with a trip to the cath lab.

I suppose the best way to avoid a January visit to the coronary care unit is to keep yourself in good shape during the rest of the year so that snow removal season isn’t such an extraordinary departure from your usual physical activity. Stay warm, get your flu shots, and watch your diet and your weight.

If there’s any question about your physical capability to shovel snow or rake ice off your roof, check with your doctor—it may be better to first try the conventional office-based stress test before you attempt the do-it-yourself-in-the-driveway method. I don’t think Dr. Netter needs any more modeling subjects for his medical atlases.

Eric Van De Graaff, MD
Eric Van De Graaff, MD

Eric Van De Graaff, MD is a Heart & Vascular Specialist at CHI Health Clinic.

Related Articles

Heart Valve Disease - Is It Worse Than Cancer?

JUN 04, 2024

Many people put up with symptoms like shortness of breath and fatigue, or explain away a heart murmur that’s actually a sign of something more serious.

Read More

Afib? Give Up Blood Thinners for Good

MAY 24, 2024

Blood-thinning medications are the long-standing treatment for Afib because they help prevent the formation of clots or break up existing clots which can cause a stroke. Unfortunately, these medications also increase your risk for bleeding.

Read More

This Stroke Risk Factor Hides in Your Heart

APR 26, 2024

Could you be walking around with a tiny hole in your heart and not know it? That’s the case for one in four people, due to an anatomic condition.

Read More